Both FHA and Conventional Cash-Out refinances let homeowners unlock home equity by replacing their current mortgage with a new, larger loan — and pocketing the difference in cash.
The difference is in who backs the loan and who it’s designed for:
FHA Cash-Out – backed by the Federal Housing Administration, easier to qualify with lower credit. Conventional Cash-Out – private lender product, ideal for borrowers with strong credit and higher equity. FHA vs Conventional Cash-Out: Side-by-Side Comparison Feature
FHA Cash-Out Refinance
Conventional Cash-Out Refinance
Minimum Credit Score 580+ (official FHA minimum) — some lenders allow 500–579 with higher down payment or tighter terms 620+ (agency minimum) — but 660+ is typical for best rates and approval Max Loan-to-Value (LTV) Up to 80% (reduced from 85% by HUD as of 2023) Up to 80% Debt-to-Income (DTI) Generally up to 50%, sometimes higher with strong compensating factors Typically ≤ 45%, up to 50% in rare cases with DU/LP approval Mortgage Insurance Required — Upfront MIP (1.75%) + Annual MIP (0.55–0.85%) for the life of the loan (if LTV > 78%) Not required if ≥20% equity; PMI applies only if <20% equity Eligible Property Types Primary residence only Primary, second home, or investment property Average 2025 Rate Range ~6.50–6.80% (typically 0.25–0.5% higher than conventional) ~6.25–6.50% (depends on credit, LTV, and occupancy) Best For Borrowers with moderate credit or limited equity; more flexible underwriting Borrowers with strong credit and ≥20% equity seeking lowest long-term cost
Key Insights FHA reduced the maximum LTV for cash-out to 80% (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-17). Conventional loans remain capped at 80% LTV for primary residences, with lower limits for second homes or investment properties. Mortgage insurance (MIP) on FHA loans cannot be removed — borrowers must refinance into a conventional loan to eliminate it. Rate spread: FHA rates are often 0.25–0.5% higher but easier to qualify for. -> See detailed Conventional Cash-Out requirements
Real Example: Comparing Both in 2025 Scenario
FHA Cash-Out
Conventional Cash-Out
Home Value $400,000 $400,000 Loan Balance $250,000 $250,000 Max Loan Amount $320,000 (80% LTV) $320,000 (80% LTV) Cash-Out $70,000 $70,000 Rate (2025 Avg.) 6.65% (with MIP) 6.35% (no MIP) Monthly Payment (est.) $2,046 $1,980 Upfront Insurance 1.75% (UFMIP) None Annual Insurance 0.55% (MIP) 0–0.5% (PMI)
-> Compare today’s cash-out refinance rates
Result:
FHA helps more borrowers qualify, especially if credit < 620. Conventional loans usually save more long-term if you have strong credit and equity. Pros and Cons at a Glance FHA Cash-Out Benefits Easier qualification (credit 500+) Government-backed for added lender confidence Great for debt consolidation or home upgrades FHA Cash-Out Drawbacks Requires Upfront + Annual MIP Higher total cost over time Only for primary residences -> Read full FHA Cash-Out guide
Conventional Cash-Out Benefits Lower rates for well-qualified borrowers No upfront insurance Works for second homes or rentals PMI can be removed after 20% equity Conventional Cash-Out Drawbacks Stricter credit & documentation Requires stable income and strong DTI Not ideal for lower credit borrowers Which Loan Is Better for You? If You…
Choose…
Have credit below 620 FHA Cash-Out Have strong credit and 20%+ equity Conventional Cash-Out Want the lowest cost over time Conventional Need flexible approval or higher DTI FHA Cash-Out
Pro Tip: Use Loan Factory’s AI-powered MOSO system to instantly compare 240+ lenders and see both FHA and Conventional options side-by-side.
Why Choose Loan Factory Loan Factory helps homeowners refinance smarter — combining AI technology, transparent pricing, and access to 240+ lenders.
Why borrowers choose us:
AI-powered MOSO platform for instant loan comparisons 240+ wholesale lenders with real-time rates No application or junk fees Guided by Thuan Nguyen – America’s #1 Loan Officer Get personalized support from a local loan advisor When you compare FHA vs Conventional Cash-Out, the right choice depends on your credit, equity, and goals:
Go FHA if you need flexible approval. Go Conventional if you want lower long-term costs. Either way, Loan Factory makes it easy to compare rates and lenders — ensuring you always get the best deal with transparent pricing and no hidden fees.
Apply online: www.LoanFactory.com/apply
Check mortgage rates: www.LoanFactory.com/quote
Set up a rate alert: www.loanfactory.com/mortgage-rate-alert
For faster support, you can call or text us at (660) 333-3333
This content is for informational purposes only and not a commitment to lend. Loan terms, rates, and approval depend on credit, underwriting, and investor guidelines.
FAQ: Compare FHA vs Conventional Cash-Out 
